West Ham will be a bad move for Reading’s Shorey

The Beeb reports that West Ham have made a 5m bid for Reading left-back Nicky Shorey. Shorey’s a good player and West Ham will improve thanks to him, but I don’t think that moving to West Ham would turn into a good career move for Shorey.

This has nothing to do with whether I like West Ham or not (so don’t go there – I like the Hammers); on the other hand it’s all about the West Ham manager and the squad currently assembled at West Ham.

I don’t think Curbishley has it in him to make West Ham into a consistent top-7 side. He could take West Ham to Uefa Cup football in one season but over the long run, all Curbishley can do is stabilize West Ham and turn them into a promising but under-achieving mid-table side.

The West Ham squad is perhaps good enough to be playing in Europe right now, but they need a lot of playing time together and without a good manager, there’s no point to it, is there?

Shorey would be better off staying at Reading for another season and then deciding on his future next summer – or if he must move, he should aim for a move to Newcastle – a club that needs a left-back, have a better manager and definitely one that has more chances of making the top 7 than West Ham.

Also Read: The Premier League 2007 Summer Transfers Page and our transfer news section.

Adriano going to: West Ham, Manchester City, Lazio or Manchester United?
Can Nugent or Anelka score 15-20 goals for Portsmouth, or will they be better off at Bolton?


  1. JMan 29 August, 2007
  2. tony 29 August, 2007
  3. Phil 29 August, 2007
  4. Brian 29 August, 2007
  5. Fifth Column 29 August, 2007
  6. Jay 29 August, 2007
  7. Rich 29 August, 2007
  8. Munky 29 August, 2007
  9. Strikarz 30 August, 2007
  10. Ballin' Billy 30 August, 2007
  11. nerazzurri 31 August, 2007