Aston Villa captain or Liverpool bench-warmer?

Looking through the Soccerlens mailbag this week we came across a letter from a Premier League player who is facing a difficult dilemma. As always, Soccerlens can help.

Dear Soccerlens,

I am faced with an impossible decision at a crucial stage in my career. I don’t know what to do for the best and I am told that you are the people to come to for advice. I certainly enjoy reading Graham Fisher’s stuff, I really don’t think he gets paid enough.

I am twenty-seven years old and am a one club man. I skipper my team and everyone here likes me. I have played at centre-half, left back, left midfield and am now one of the best central midfield players in the country. I must be because I’ve got eighteen England caps to prove it. So put that in your pipe in smoke it.

I enjoy playing for my club and this season we have made a serious challenge for fifth place. Next season, I think we could mount a serious challenge for fifth place and in the medium to long term, we could have the potential to become the fifth best team in England.

My manager has made it clear that he wants to keep me at the club saying that he is ‘desperate’ and would ‘do anything to keep me.’ I’m afraid I’m just not that way inclined so he’d better not try it.

I have two years of my contract left to run and have already proved myself to be a loyal club servant. My word is my bond, so I shouldn’t go against it.

I have played over three hundred games for my club and the fans and players love me. They know how important I am to the clubs plans and ambitions to stay exactly where we currently are.

I get paid well at my club, but it is nothing like as much as I would get if I moved to Liverpool or Chelsea, for example.

So there is my dilemma in a nutshell Soccerlens, I just don’t know what to do. I have to make the choice. Do I stay or do I go?

If I stay, I will get paid OK, might get the odd England cap and if we’re incredibly lucky, might finish fifth and get to play against Buducnost Podgorica or HSK Zrinjski Mostar in the UEFA Cup.

If I go, I will get paid a fortune, could become an England regular and will win trophies and probably get to at least the semi-final of the Champions League.

It is such a tough choice. Help me Soccerlens.

GB, Aston, Birmingham, England.

Soccerlens reply – Dear GB,

You certainly have a tough decision to make there and I’m glad I’m not in your shoes. Anonymity in a quite good team or super stardom with potential European Champions? How on Earth can you choose between the two?

I think, if it were me, I would stay where I was and show a selfless loyalty, paying back the club for the eleven years of hard work and salary they have put in to you to get you to where you are now. I wouldn’t run off to where the grass is undoubtedly greener just to further my own career and set myself up for life.

There is more to life than success, happiness, health, wealth, excitement and adoration around the world, you know. Maybe you should also consider the possibility that if you go to the one of the big clubs you might not be very good and might not play much.

You should show the same sort of loyalty to your current club that I show to this website. When others have offered me a blank cheque to write articles for them, I have always said, no. I stay with Soccerlens where I get paid nearly a pound some weeks, because I am a totally loyal sort.

GB, you could learn a lot from me. Whatever you decide to do, you must choose wisely. Money, fame, success and a life of luxury, or stay where you are.

I just don’t know how you will ever decide.

Your problems answered every Monday at Soccerlens.

Graham Fisher writes at Views of a fan.

Manchester United still favourites against Barcelona at OT
La Liga week 34: Real Madrid need just two points from four games


  1. AL 28 April, 2008
  2. Graham Fisher 28 April, 2008
  3. Melski 28 April, 2008
  4. Pedro 28 April, 2008
  5. Will 28 April, 2008
  6. Jonny boy 28 April, 2008
  7. Jonah 28 April, 2008
  8. Ahmed Bilal 28 April, 2008
  9. Liverpool_Fan 28 April, 2008
  10. Arvin 28 April, 2008
  11. Ahmed Bilal 28 April, 2008
  12. magnumopus 28 April, 2008
  13. Jonah 28 April, 2008
  14. malc 28 April, 2008
  15. Macca 28 April, 2008
  16. michael 28 April, 2008
  17. USAalltheway 28 April, 2008
  18. Tripp 28 April, 2008
  19. Lord Villa 28 April, 2008
  20. jackson 28 April, 2008
  21. Welsh Villa 29 April, 2008
  22. jos 29 April, 2008
  23. Fateh 29 April, 2008
  24. Welsh Villa 29 April, 2008
  25. malc 29 April, 2008
  26. AL 29 April, 2008
  27. AL 29 April, 2008
  28. malc 29 April, 2008
  29. Marco Pantanella 29 April, 2008
  30. Superweichselbauma 29 April, 2008
  31. welshvilla 29 April, 2008
  32. AL 30 April, 2008
  33. malc 30 April, 2008
  34. welsh villa 30 April, 2008
  35. Muffin 30 April, 2008
  36. malc 30 April, 2008
  37. welsh villa 30 April, 2008
  38. Anser 30 April, 2008
  39. welsh villa 30 April, 2008
  40. malc 4 May, 2008
  41. welsh villa 5 May, 2008
  42. Muffin 5 May, 2008
  43. Aaron 29 May, 2009