Would you have signed Carlos Tevez?

He says he wants to come to Manchester United, and United say that they’re doing everything possible to get him.

But if you had a chance (talking to non-United fans here), would you have signed Tevez for your club? If so, would he have slotted in straight into the starting lineup or taken a spot on the bench?

I’d especially like to hear views from Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Tottenham and Newcastle fans – let’s assume that the legal wrangles will be sorted out much like they were in Mascherano’s transfer to Liverpool.

What then?

Would you sign Tevez, and where would he start?

3 reasons why Babel for Liverpool is a good move at 13.5m
Who's better than Cristiano Ronaldo?

73 Comments

  1. Nathan 10 July, 2007
  2. sani 10 July, 2007
  3. cbbennett 10 July, 2007
  4. spizzy 10 July, 2007
  5. TomasHH 10 July, 2007
  6. Red Ranter 10 July, 2007
  7. karl 10 July, 2007
  8. karl 10 July, 2007
  9. karl 10 July, 2007
  10. Winston 10 July, 2007
  11. Jordan 10 July, 2007
  12. MDH 10 July, 2007
  13. De_Roiste 10 July, 2007
  14. Kop4ever 10 July, 2007
  15. Nathan 10 July, 2007
  16. Rear Gunner 10 July, 2007
  17. ENR 10 July, 2007
  18. villa 10 July, 2007
  19. andrew 10 July, 2007
  20. ENR 10 July, 2007
  21. ronaldo_diver 10 July, 2007
  22. Nathan 10 July, 2007
  23. Cheeseman 10 July, 2007
  24. ENR 10 July, 2007
  25. spizzy 10 July, 2007
  26. avrv 10 July, 2007
  27. karl 10 July, 2007
  28. karl 10 July, 2007
  29. Reds of Manchester 10 July, 2007
  30. C 'los 10 July, 2007
  31. ATLilywhite 10 July, 2007
  32. Brian W 10 July, 2007
  33. Reds of Manchester 10 July, 2007
  34. Brian W 10 July, 2007
  35. Brian W 10 July, 2007
  36. Reds of Manchester 10 July, 2007
  37. Brian W 10 July, 2007
  38. Andrei 10 July, 2007
  39. Andrei 10 July, 2007
  40. Brian W 10 July, 2007
  41. Fifth Column 11 July, 2007
  42. cbbennett 11 July, 2007
  43. karl 11 July, 2007
  44. Martino 11 July, 2007
  45. Reds of Manchester 11 July, 2007
  46. a Red fan 11 July, 2007
  47. kridz1@arsenal88 11 July, 2007
  48. Imran 11 July, 2007
  49. NYSpursFan 11 July, 2007
  50. Fifth Column 11 July, 2007
  51. Brian W 11 July, 2007
  52. ENR 11 July, 2007
  53. ENR 11 July, 2007
  54. da devil 11 July, 2007
  55. DUUDELOVE 11 July, 2007
  56. Brian W 11 July, 2007
  57. Brian W 11 July, 2007
  58. Liam O'Kelly 12 July, 2007
  59. ourfowler 12 July, 2007
  60. elemenop 12 July, 2007
  61. Fifth Column 12 July, 2007
  62. Ahmed Bilal 12 July, 2007
  63. Brian W 12 July, 2007
  64. elemenop 12 July, 2007
  65. jlad 4 August, 2007
  66. hannood 5 August, 2007
  67. hannood 6 August, 2007
  68. AK 6 August, 2007
  69. Liverpool_Fan 6 August, 2007
  70. MDH 6 August, 2007
  71. hannood 6 August, 2007
  72. Brianaldo 11 August, 2007
  73. danquah gideon 26 September, 2008