Berbatov vs McCarthy, vote for the better striker

Mark Hughes’ comments about Blackburn’s McCarthy being a better than Tottenham’s Berbatov are based on statistics.

The thing with statistics is though, that they don’t tell you everything.

Out of curiosity, I looked up the goal scoring charts for the 2006/2007 Premier League season, and here’s what I found.

Top scorers from Blackburn and Tottenham (3 goals or more):

Benni McCarthy, 16, Blackburn Rovers
Dimitar Berbatov, 11, Tottenham
Robbie Keane, 10, Tottenham
Jermaine Defoe, 9, Tottenham
Shabani Nonda, 7, Blackburn
Pedersen, 6, Blackburn
Jenas, 6, Tottenham
Derbyshire, 4, Blackburn
Roberts, 4, Blackburn
Bentley, 3, Blackburn
Lennon, 3, Tottenham

To put Lennon’s goals in perspective, Gallas has 3 to his name, O’Shea has 4 and Park Ji-Sung has 5.

The point is, player quality and stats don’t always go hand in hand.

So who’s the better player?

Register your votes below.

Big Sam will bring the discipline Newcastle so badly need
West Ham's troubles with Wigan and Sheffield United are far from over

28 Comments

  1. De_Roiste 10 May, 2007
  2. robbie howie 10 May, 2007
  3. Jay 10 May, 2007
  4. Essex_Yid 10 May, 2007
  5. Shannon 10 May, 2007
  6. Toby 10 May, 2007
  7. Scott 10 May, 2007
  8. Ahmed Bilal 10 May, 2007
  9. Toby 10 May, 2007
  10. Karl 10 May, 2007
  11. Rob 10 May, 2007
  12. Ahmed Bilal 10 May, 2007
  13. estebanrey 10 May, 2007
  14. estebanrey 10 May, 2007
  15. Nick 10 May, 2007
  16. Shaheen Seedat 10 May, 2007
  17. AS 11 May, 2007
  18. AS 11 May, 2007
  19. ben 11 May, 2007
  20. stato 11 May, 2007
  21. Jae Dave 11 May, 2007
  22. bondyboy 11 May, 2007
  23. Scott 11 May, 2007
  24. Scott 11 May, 2007
  25. kakalegend 12 May, 2007
  26. slaton 12 May, 2007
  27. bitchslap bill 25 June, 2007
  28. Simon 31 August, 2007