Nani, Bale, Tottenham and Manchester United

I’ve said this before, but it is worth repeating – Tottenham have brought in an excellent talent in Gareth Bale, and they’ve got him at the right price as well.

Now the rumour-mill has gone into overdrive with papers suggesting that Nani is also headed towards White Hart Lane, with the Spurs set to pull off another transfer coup.

Let’s look at this rationally, shall we?

One, I don’t understand why Manchester United didn’t move for Bale. My only guess is that United would not have given him regular football, at least in the first season and that put off any pre-contractual talks.

Is Bale better than Evra? There’s a good chance he is as good, and at 17, he’s bound to keep improving (he’ll be 18 by August, I think).

5m for a left-back, when you already have 3 others, may be considered too Chelsea-esque but in my view 2 of our 3 left-backs (Evra and Silvestre) should be sold this summer and if you keep that in mind then bringing in Bale would have been a very good idea.

I sure as hell hope that in the long-run Ferguson got this one right, because United definitely should have acquired Bale.

Two, I don’t see how the Bale / Nani situations are related, and why the media are spinning them as such. It makes little sense for Nani to leave a club with Champions league opportunities and go play for a club that only has an outside chance of playing in the Champions League – it’s a demotion, and once again if you go by the player’s comments then Nani to Tottenham seems unlikely.

However, Manchester United may not have Nani at the top winger on their list. And with the new ‘contract’ still unconfirmed, there’s enough evidence to suggest that at the moment the Nani situation is pretty open.

We can speculate and punt all we want, but ultimately it depends on Ferguson – and we’re all waiting for him to make his bloody move.

Transfer season is never fun 🙂

A quick update on Manchester United, Nani and Anderson
Why Ribery to Bayern doesn't make sense

61 Comments

  1. Gee 29 May, 2007
  2. jollyboysouting 29 May, 2007
  3. Nick 29 May, 2007
  4. Paul 29 May, 2007
  5. spursman 29 May, 2007
  6. Bjarkovic 29 May, 2007
  7. spursman 29 May, 2007
  8. Ryan 29 May, 2007
  9. Nick 29 May, 2007
  10. Clayton Simpson 29 May, 2007
  11. toby 29 May, 2007
  12. suraj 29 May, 2007
  13. Nick 29 May, 2007
  14. Tomas 29 May, 2007
  15. Jonesy 29 May, 2007
  16. Ahmed Bilal 29 May, 2007
  17. Tottenham4Eva 29 May, 2007
  18. sam 29 May, 2007
  19. h 29 May, 2007
  20. h 29 May, 2007
  21. zed 30 May, 2007
  22. Aries 30 May, 2007
  23. RedLyon 30 May, 2007
  24. Hugo Steckelmacher 30 May, 2007
  25. Paul 30 May, 2007
  26. Wayne King 30 May, 2007
  27. Wayne King 30 May, 2007
  28. sam g 30 May, 2007
  29. delroy carnegie 30 May, 2007
  30. zed 30 May, 2007
  31. rob 30 May, 2007
  32. Zack 30 May, 2007
  33. srizzel 30 May, 2007
  34. De_Roiste 30 May, 2007
  35. Xs 30 May, 2007
  36. zed 30 May, 2007
  37. De_Roiste 30 May, 2007
  38. Tomas 30 May, 2007
  39. delroy carnegie 30 May, 2007
  40. Tomas 30 May, 2007
  41. chime 30 May, 2007
  42. we have the best young players in the world 31 May, 2007
  43. Xs 31 May, 2007
  44. we have the best young players in the world 31 May, 2007
  45. Nick 31 May, 2007
  46. Tomas 31 May, 2007
  47. AK 31 May, 2007
  48. Tomas 31 May, 2007
  49. Nick 31 May, 2007
  50. Nick 31 May, 2007
  51. SportingFan 31 May, 2007
  52. Tomas 31 May, 2007
  53. Nick 31 May, 2007
  54. Nick 31 May, 2007
  55. Tomas 31 May, 2007
  56. Nick 31 May, 2007
  57. SportingFan 31 May, 2007
  58. Ahmed Bilal 31 May, 2007
  59. Sporting 31 May, 2007
  60. Aries 31 May, 2007
  61. Mutende 24 July, 2007